It’s Not That They’re Not Listening
What we might be missing when a child doesn’t respond the way we expect
The moment I keep meeting
There are moments I keep finding myself in, and they’ve long been one of the most challenging edges in my parenting.
I say something to my 8-year-old, P — call her name, ask a question, remind her of something we’ve already talked about — and what comes back doesn’t match what I expected. Sometimes there’s no response at all. Sometimes she continues as if I haven’t spoken. Sometimes she answers, but drifts away while I’m still replying.
And almost instantly, I feel something build in me. A tightening, a heat in my belly, a sharpness to my voice that wasn’t there a moment before. It feels like a shift from connection into something more urgent, more controlling, more certain.
She’s not listening.
And almost as quickly — she doesn’t listen.
It feels like a simple description of reality, but I’ve gradually come to see that it isn’t neutral. It’s an interpretation – and one that arrives so quickly it’s almost invisible.
A familiar scene, seen again
One moment that has stayed with me happened in the car a few months ago. P and I were sharing something light — her little sister had fallen asleep, and we were laughing together about how funny she looked, her mouth wide open. P leaned across to look more closely and, in that playful energy, reached out and touched D’s mouth.
I said gently, “No, don’t do that.” She did it again. I said “stop”, more firmly this time, and within seconds it escalated. She continued, D — a light sleeper — woke up, and I felt that surge of frustration flood through me. By the time we got home, I was telling her — again — that she didn’t listen, that this keeps happening, that she needs to stop.
She ended up in tears, saying she was “the worst girl in the world.”
Later, when things had settled, she said something that didn’t fit the story I had already built.
“I hear you Mum… but I can’t get my brain to stop.”
The speed of meaning
What I’ve started to notice is how quickly meaning gets assigned in these moments, and how little awareness I have of that process while it’s happening. Something is said, the response doesn’t match, and almost immediately it becomes “she’s not listening again”. From there, it easily slides into defiance, inattention, or choice — even if those words never fully form.
It feels as though I’m responding to what she’s doing, but often I’m responding to what I’ve decided it means. Underneath that is an assumption I didn’t realise I was carrying — that if she was listening, she would show me in a way I recognise. She would respond, stop, follow through.
But that definition doesn’t hold across what I’m actually seeing.
The many forms of “not listening”
Part of what has made this so confusing is that “not listening” doesn’t show up in one consistent way. With P, it has looked like missing things entirely at times — something that was once complicated further by hearing difficulties. It has looked like complete absorption in something else, where I can say her name multiple times and not reach her at all. It has looked like hearing me but continuing anyway, or asking a question and then walking off while I’m answering, or asking again about something we’ve just discussed.
All of these moments can trigger the same reaction in me, but they are not the same experience from her side. When I slow it down, I can see that very different things are happening underneath what looks, on the surface, like the same behaviour.
I’m also aware that this doesn’t show up in the same way for every child. Some orient more readily to others, to structure, and to what’s being asked of them. Others — like P — can be deeply absorptive, pulled into what they’re inside of in a way that makes shifting or responding much harder. Which means these moments can feel more frequent and more easily misread — not because something is wrong, but because attention and responsiveness are shaped differently.
Listening — but not agreeing
There are many moments where P has heard me clearly but has a different sense of what should happen next. She might be in the middle of building something or following a thread of imagination that feels important to her, and I come in with a request to stop or move on. From my perspective, it can look like she’s ignoring me, but from hers, she is holding a clear internal priority.
What matters to her in that moment is the thing she’s inside of — the idea, the creation, the momentum she’s following. When I meet that as defiance, I’m missing what’s actually there.
Not a lack of listening, but a difference in perspective.
Listening — but unable to stop
Then there are moments where the issue isn’t agreement at all, but capacity. The moment in the car brought this into sharp focus. By the time my words reached her, her body was already in motion, and what I was asking — “stop” — required a level of inhibition that wasn’t available to her in that moment.
Her words stayed with me because they were so clear: she had heard me, but she couldn’t translate that into action quickly enough to interrupt what was already happening.
This is where something deeper began to shift for me.
Because much of what I had absorbed — through my training, through developmental frameworks, through the systems I’d been shaped by — assumed a level of control that children simply don’t yet have. We ask for responses that rely on inhibition, sequencing, and self-regulation that are still developing, and then interpret the absence of those responses as choice.
But what if the expectation itself is part of the misreading?
Listening — but at a different pace
There is another form this takes, which is quieter and easier to miss. It shows up in the pause — the delay — the moment where I say something and nothing appears to happen. With both P and D, I can see how often I’ve stepped in too early here, repeating myself or firming my tone, only to be met with frustration that they were “just about to”.
What I had taken as ignoring was, from their side, a process already underway. Not finished yet, not visible yet, but in motion.
I’ve noticed this particularly around transitions. Moving from one activity to another seems to require a kind of internal reorganisation that takes time. When that time is compressed, P can become overwhelmed or frustrated, sometimes turning that frustration inward. When there is space, she arrives more fully and more willingly.
It has made me question the idea that children have a fixed attention span or predictable response time. What I see instead is that attention shifts with context, with interest, with relationship and environment.
What looks like inconsistency is often information.
What urgency does to perception
The thread running through all of this is not just about P, but about what happens in me. The speed of my interpretation is driven by urgency — a felt need to be heard, to be responded to, to bring things back into line.
I can feel it in my body as heat and intensity, and when it’s there, my capacity to see her narrows. She hasn’t changed, but my ability to understand what’s happening has.
Urgency doesn’t just make me act faster. It reduces what I’m able to perceive.
Where this starts to unravel
Alongside this, there has been a broader unravelling happening for me. The systems I was shaped by, the professional training I received, the developmental expectations I absorbed — all of them positioned the child in a particular way. A child who should be able to listen, respond, regulate, and comply within externally defined timelines, and in ways that are visible and consistent.
When that doesn’t happen, we reach for explanations that fit the framework: she doesn’t listen, she’s inattentive, she’s defiant.
But more and more, I can see how often those labels are standing in for something we haven’t fully understood — and how often they reflect a mismatch between what we expect and what a child is actually capable of in that moment.
What I’m questioning is not whether listening matters. Of course it does. But I’ve started to see how often what we call “listening” is actually something narrower — something closer to immediate compliance, measured by how quickly a child overrides what is happening inside them in favour of what is coming from outside.
And I’m beginning to wonder what develops instead when listening is understood more broadly — not just as responding to us, but as staying connected to what is happening within, while gradually learning to hold others in mind too.
What begins to change
These moments haven’t disappeared, and I still feel the surge of frustration more often than I would like. But something has shifted in how quickly meaning settles. There are times now where I can pause, even briefly, and consider that she may have heard me, even if she hasn’t responded in the way I expected.
I’m starting to separate listening from agreement, understanding from immediate action, intention from capacity. I’m noticing how much of what I was reacting to came from my own conditioning rather than from what was actually happening in front of me.
It hasn’t made everything easier, but it has created space. And in that space, something different becomes possible.
It’s not that they’re not listening.
Sometimes they’re disagreeing, sometimes they’re already in motion, and sometimes they’re still integrating. And sometimes, what we’re responding to has more to do with how quickly meaning is being made than with what the child is actually doing.
If this piece stirred something, I’d love to hear.
Where do you notice yourself moving quickly from what’s happening into what it means?
What shifts when you stay with the moment a little longer, before deciding your child isn’t listening?
Your reflections often help others recognise what they’re already sensing.
If this felt familiar — that sense that something isn’t quite what it first appears to be — I offer 1:1 sessions where we explore this more closely.
These are grounded conversations where we look at what’s actually happening in real time, so you can respond to your child as they are, rather than through the lens of urgency or assumption.
This isn’t about getting children to listen better.
It’s about seeing clearly enough to understand what you’re already looking at.
If you’d like to stay connected to this work, you are very welcome to subscribe to receive future pieces.
There’s also the option to become a paid subscriber if you’d like to support it more directly.
All writing will remain open — but your support helps sustain the time and space this work needs.